Bond…School Bond

KingstonBarn Photo

KingstonBarn Photo

The Kingston School Bond Vote is tomorrow.  Simply put, the school district is asking for us to borrow $137 million to fix the tremendous problems of the hundred-year-old Kingston High School physical plant.  If the bond passes, construction is scheduled to begin in 2015, or about the same time as the SUNY Ulster’s Sophie Finn campus is completed right across from the high school.

The Kingston City School District has published some information on their site.

From brick falling out of walls, to antiquated steam heat, to buildings that have to come down, the work has been neglected for far too long.  One friend, a 1950’s graduate of KHS, says some of the existing troubles have been around since she was a student.

How we got to this place has been discussed at length.  Neglect, bad decisions, short budgets, and age have all been a part of the picture.  I won’t go over old ground.  Our decision now is to pass the bond or not.  The question hinges on what we want for the centerpiece of our public schools, and literally, our city.

At $137 million over the life of the bond, this is no small question.  Even with the state kicking in 60% of the tab, the Kingston City School District figures that the annual cost to each homeowner will be about $0.72 per thousand of assessed value, or nearly $100 in our case.  Can we find another eight or nine dollars a month to pay for this?  Probably, but the city and county tax will ask for more, and our insurance bill doesn’t go down.  It’s a lot to ask.

One argument circulating against the project is that our school population may not meet the Superintendent’s ten-year projections.  This does not hold water.  Whether we choose to educate 1600 or 2400 students in dangerous, dilapidated buildings is immaterial.

I have heard people ask why, if they don’t send their kids to Kingston schools, should they care?  They pay taxes, but they get nothing for it, the thinking goes.

What we get is a high school.  What we get is an anchor for the schools, for Midtown, and for Kingston.  What we do now is a decision on whether the anchor gives us a mooring spot or drags us down.


KingstonBarn Photo

People are looking at all of Kingston when they make the decision whether to move here.  The owners and officers of businesses considering a new home need to know what we have for their families.  One thing I know for sure is that people won’t want to move here, and businesses will not want to locate their families here if there is no decent school to send their kids.

If we don’t pass this now, Superintendent Paul Padalino says, “it’s back to the drawing board.”  There is no cheaper Plan B waiting to take its place.  Construction costs are not going to go down over the next five years.  Compliance with codes, heating, asbestos remediation, and the Americans with Disabilities Act are not optional.  Emergencies are always more expensive than good plans.

I have just one vote, but I am going to cast it for the plan.

-Andrew Champ-Doran


Posted by on December 9, 2013 in Uncategorized


Tags: , ,

The Heart of the Matter

Desperation.  Frustration.  Resignation.  Resolve.  You can hear all of that when you listen to Renato DiBella.

KingstonBarn Photo

KingstonBarn Photo

He’s owned DiBella’s Pizza at the corner of Washington Avenue and Marius Street for the last sixteen years.   Thank you, Mr DiBella.  Thank you for working for your business, your employees, and your neighbors.

He has fought for and worked in this neighborhood all of that time.  In the beginning, he took out a small business loan from the City with just two employees.  He finished paying it off three years ahead of schedule, and grew his business to eleven employees.  No plaque, no recognition, no official thank you.  He hasn’t asked for any.  He just keeps it going, hiring people from all over the neighborhood.

His fight is bigger now.  Extraordinary circumstances have become ordinary days.

Most of you know that the sinkhole on Washington Avenue has been the city’s biggest problem for the last two years.  We have put nearly four million dollars into repairs and fixes over that time.  People who live and work in the area of the hole, and have been affected by traffic and repairs and surveying should be commended for their patience.  The people that live closest should be nominated for sainthood.  They have put up with broken sewer lines, water stoppages, cracked foundations, sewer gas smells, loss of yards and privacy, and homes with little or no value on the open market.  DiBella’s has been there a long time, but, without the business the closed street has taken, they have to move.  Other people want to move, but can’t.  Some don’t want to, but can’t see the end.  All of them just want their lives back.

These people have paid so much in dues that we owe them change.

Mostly, the people here feel that they have not really been listened to.  “If this had happened on Albany Avenue or Broadway, this would have been done by now”, one said.  We can’t leave them feeling like their complaints are the problem.  Their complaints are just describing the symptoms of the illness.

They have been to their Aldermen, their Mayors, their Assemblyman, and their Governor.

Renato DiBella soldiers on.  So do his neighbors.  They all know each other.  Their lives have crossed for years.  He is one story in this neighborhood, and he is going to stay here.   He still owns the building, and has other properties nearby.  His family lives here.

The sinkhole is a big problem, and it belongs to the entire city.

KingstonBarn Photo

KingstonBarn Photo

What can we can do for each other?  How can we turn this into a model city?  Well, we can advocate for others in city hall.  We can make a difference if we speak to the common council at meetings, or just be there to hear a neighbor who does.    Can it be as simple as cutting our own bushes back at the corners so people can see oncoming traffic?  None of these things will increase taxes, but they will add value to real lives.  Do we really need “official” Make a Difference Days?  Renato passionately explained that it is expected and ordinary that we all come together in a crisis and, of course, it is valued.  However, it is how we come together and connect on ordinary days that makes a difference.

I want to represent and champion Kingston neighbors like Renato while serving on the Kingston Common Council.  KingstonBarn came from the desire to bring people together, and find out what we can do to help Kingston.  We can stay positive and work together.

I believe together we can make our ordinary days extraordinary.  It is my desire, my passion, my heart.  It is a mission which can inspire and unite all of our 3rd Ward residents and the Kingston City community.

We don’t have all the answers, but who would we be if we stopped trying to find them?

-Andrew Champ-Doran

Leave a comment

Posted by on November 3, 2013 in Uncategorized


Tags: , , , ,

Vote for Andrew Champ-Doran



Election Day:  Tuesday, November 5.  Here in Ward 3, we vote at the George Washington School.  The polls are open from 6:00 AM to 9:00 PM.  I am asking for your support and your vote.  Make a plan to get out and vote.

Regular readers of this blog know my belief that we can accomplish something if we work together.  You know that I am willing to do the work.  The people here are certainly willing to make things happen in the City of Kingston.

My work has garnered the endorsements of the Republican Party, the Independence Party.  I have been endorsed by Mayor Shayne Gallo, the Kingston Professional Fire Fighters Association, Republican Alderman Nathaniel Horowitz, and former Democratic Alderman Lenny Walker.  My greatest honor, though, is the support and advice you have given me.  I promise to do everything I can to earn it, every day.

Don’t forget to flip the ballot over and vote on our 6 ballot measures.  If you didn’t get my earlier post about that, here’s a link to the League of Women Voters Guide that explains them all.

Please read this letter, and I’ll see you at the polls.

To the People of Ward 3 and the City of Kingston,

I am honored to continue in the race for Alderman of our Ward 3.  I hold the Republican and Independence lines on the Ballot on November 5, and I am working to earn the chance to represent the people here.  I am out every day, trying to reach everyone in the Ward, regardless of party affiliation or voter registration.  It is what I have done from the start.  It may not be the way to win a one-party primary, but I don’t believe you can effectively represent people if you are unwilling to talk to 3/4 of them until after an election.  For me, it has always been about all residents of our Third Ward, not political advancement or motivations.

Service as 3rd Ward Alderman is not a stepping stone to higher office.  It is the job I want to do.  I am asking for your vote.

I am proud and humbled by the support and endorsements I have received from a broad spectrum of people and organizations. I believe it is a testament to the quality of being able to work effectively with many different personalities which resonates with my supporters.

For my part, I think we have a real chance to move the Common Council again.  We can work to come up with creative solutions, or we can sit back and bemoan the problems, and attack the people trying to do something.  I have been working with officials and people to help with our problems in schools and hospitals, our commercial and residential corridors, and general quality of life issues that affect all of us.  Our infrastructure is old, and it’s not going to maintain or improve itself.  If we abandon the Washington Avenue sinkhole, we abandon the sewer line for over one third of Kingston.  How many years, and how many millions of dollars would that cost to replace?

We have a tiller fire truck that is in need of replacement, and an engine that broke down again, this time at a fire in the Third Ward.  If we don’t do what it takes to replace those as soon as we can, the fire rating we are awarded will drop, and the insurance rates of everyone in this city will skyrocket.  The cost for you and me to own our homes, and the cost of rentals, will most assuredly increase.

I have promised you updates and regular communication, I have promised to answer your questions with honesty and as completely as possible, and I have promised to listen to you and everyone else in the 3rd Ward.  I have consistently held to those commitments.

Simply put, I am interested in building a better Kingston as 3rd Ward Alderman.  Vote for Andrew Champ-Doran.  I’ll work hard for you.

Andrew Champ-Doran    Candidate for Alderman  Ward 3

The Champ-Doran Family

The Champ-Doran Family

Leave a comment

Posted by on November 3, 2013 in Uncategorized


Tags: , , ,

KingstonBarn on Kingston NOW

Over a year ago, KingstonBarn was born out of a need for civil discourse on the events and problems that affect us here in our home.  The goal was to create a jumping-off place for thought and discussion that might lead to answers.  I have been pleased with KingstonBarn’s progress.  Readership is up, as are the frequency of comments.  I haven’t published all of the comments, because I ask people to submit their real names, but even the anonymous contributions have been thoughtful and helpful.  I try to pass them along informally to the subjects and in conversations, so I want you to know that you, Anonymous, are still participating.

KingstonBarn is earning some recognition, and this is about an experience I had recently with the group of barn builders over at Kingston NOW.

In May, at the opening of State Senator Cecelia Tkaczyk’s uptown Kingston office, I had the pleasure of meeting Jimmy Buff, Producer and Host of Kingston NOW, a show I have been watching on the web since last year.  I’m a fan, and I told him so, to which he said, “So, you’re the one.”  Perfect timing, I must say.  After briefly discussing KingstonBarn and Kingston NOW, Jimmy asked me to come shoot a segment for the show.  A little further in the conversation, he also asked that I discuss my upcoming candidacy for 3rd Ward Alderman here in the City of Kingston.  You can click on the embedded video and see the show as it appears on YouTube.  My segment occupies the middle six or seven minutes, but the whole show is worth a viewing at your leisure.  If you prefer, you can click on Kingston NOW’s YouTube Channel.  That way, Kingston now can track their number of views.

Since August of 2011, Kingston NOW airs locally Wednesdays on Time Warner’s RNN, Channel 22.  Executive Producer Jeremy Ellenbogen tells me they have over 100 shows to their credit, with nearly that many appearing on their YouTube channel.  To now, the show has focused largely on local issues, shooting most segments in Ellenbogen’s 721 Media Center right here on Broadway.  After RNN moved their Kingston operations to their Rye Brook home base, Ellenbogen says, “they requested we do a show so they could keep a foot in Kingston.” Adding “it’s been great for us as well,” he says this remains the only locally produced regular program about our area.

Host Jimmy Buff is the lynchpin to the success of the show.  At the center of a professional production team, he is unusually curious, and seems genuinely interested in his guests’ views.  He is well prepared, has notes, but will pay attention to the interviewees, and isn’t afraid to let conversations take a natural path.  He listens, and he is generous with his guests.  Buff lets the subjects speak for themselves.  He doesn’t cut them off, but he won’t leave them hanging, either.  Both extremes are real fears for novice guests like me, but he makes it seem just a conversation that simply ends too soon.

Anybody who lives, works, or spends time in Kingston is a part of our community, and the crew over at Kingston NOW are community builders.  Watch it, share it, and help spread the word.  This is too good to keep just between us.

Kingston NOW is one of the jewels of our city, and it’s expanding beyond our local boundaries.  Ellenbogen says they will be branching out, covering other happenings in our part of Ulster County and beyond, but they will remain focused on and anchored in their home port of Kingston.  Thank goodness for that.

Andrew Champ-Doran

Leave a comment

Posted by on August 3, 2013 in Uncategorized


Tags: , , , ,

Some Paneling Would Work Well In Here

In the Daily Freeman’s Thursday article “Kingston panel, if formed, would field public’s infrastructure concerns“, Mayor Shayne Gallo proposes a committee of our lawmakers to define and address some of the infrastructure problems that affect residents and visitors of our city.

Repairs underway at Gilead -KingstonBarn photo

Repairs underway at Gilead -KingstonBarn photo

This seems to be an excellent opportunity for the Kingston Common Council to add value to their already important work. We have an aging infrastructure that is badly in need of attention, and residents need to know what’s going on with the essential systems that support our everyday life.

One problem here is that sewers, buried cable, the undersides of bridges, and road beds are invisible until they fail, so it’s hard to know where to pay attention until a catastrophic failure happens. We don’t have to go very deep into the past to find examples; the Twaalfskill at Gilead and Wilbur, the sinkhole on Washington between Linderman and Donovan place, and shutting gas off to a third of the city on a cold winter night. Others, like the recently de-certified berm behind the Kinston Plaza, are coming, and maybe this committee can play a crucial role in getting the jump on those.

When I told Ward 2’s Thomas Hoffay that I was considering a run for Alderman in the 3rd Ward, he told me to always remember that the Common Council is a co-equal partner in government with the Mayor’s office. Wise words, Mr. Hoffay, and advice I take to heart.

Some will see this as adding another layer of government between problems and solutions, but I see it as an opportunity to use the vital resources of people already intimately involved with the problems that affect the neighborhood. Take advantage of the Aldermen communicating between City hall and the residents of the wards. Put to use the warnings of people that “smell that awful smell”, or notice that 3 or 4 of the street lights are out, even though they’ve already called Central Hudson.

Of course, the question of paying for it remains a tough one.  As my old news editor used to say, “Sewers ain’t sexy, but you gotta have ’em.”  How do we cover our needs without raising our taxes?  Well, the DEC, seems to make funds available for emergency fixes.  Maybe they have ready money for prevention.  It’s only one thought, but I am sure that prevention costs are less than the cure.

This panel has the potential to reach out to neighbors after the initial problem is fixed.  Under standards set by the Common Council, City agencies can help the people nearby put their homes, land, and lives back in order. This could help solve some liability issues, avoiding some of the lawsuits that often come along as a result.  An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, but only if we use the ounce.  This committee’s job would be to identify the ounces and the pounds.

The Sinkhole at Washington -KingstonBarn photo by Quentin Champ-Doran

The Sinkhole at Washington -KingstonBarn photo by Quentin Champ-Doran

Andrew Champ-Doran


Since logging the above, Alderman-at-Large James Noble has announced a three member subcommittee to address the issues noted.  Appearing in today’s Daily Freeman, “Kingston panel to focus on infrastructure” outlines Alderman Noble’s plan to move forward with this important work.  Well done.

Leave a comment

Posted by on July 22, 2013 in Uncategorized


Tags: , , , , ,

It’s All Wrong But It’s All Right

Governor Andrew Cuomo has given us quite a lot to think about in the last couple of weeks, and not all of it is pleasant.

He has told us that municipalities and school districts are not consolidating services and constituencies fast enough, and costing the taxpayers money.  He’s told us that the schools are going to see no more money from the state in the coming budget.  He’s told us the budget is coming out, and we will all have to tighten our belts a little more.  New York, he says, can’t afford to do any more.  Sure, there is a tax cap, but the Governor assures us there is no mandate relief in site for our counties, towns, or schools.

“Do more with less,’ just about sums it up.Do more with less

It’s disheartening, then, to see this headline in the Kingston Daily Freeman:  NY Gov. Andrew Cuomo allows state police superintendent to draw $85,000 pension, plus $136,000 salary  According to the AP story, Governor Cuomo has filed for a waiver to pay State Police Superintendent Joseph D’Amico his NYPD pension while he is earning the full salary and benefits afforded his current position.  Cuomo’s reasoning for breaking his previous pledge not to do so? “…it had become “financially impossible” for him to keep his post without it.”  Somehow, while working that old saw, the top people in our state government cannot manage to do more with less.

I don’t know Mr. D’Amico’s age, his abilities, or his financial situation. It’s really none of my business. I would not presume to tell him which of his necessities or luxuries to forgo, but I am sure he’s earned whatever he has.

I do assume that, after being nominated for the post by the Governor, and gaining confirmation by the Legislature, Joseph D’Amico is qualified for the job.  He has already lasted longer than his three predecessors combined.  That is not the question.  Being paid by the state to work while taking your full retirement benefit is.

If you cannot afford to retire, keep your job. This is the choice millions make every day, and they make a whole lot less than $85,000 per year. If you cannot afford to do the job for what it pays, your choices are a little broader. Negotiate for more, don’t take the job, or find one that can support you.  The answer, from the Governor’s point of view, should not be to give a back-door pay increase, but to do it openly if he feels it’s warranted.  How can we hold our local police and fire personnel to higher standards than the state holds theirs? photo photo

I am not implying any malfeasance, criminal activity, or cover-up.  What Governor Cuomo has done is perfectly legal, and, judging by the numbers, is in keeping with past practice.  I am saying that this gives at least the appearance of impropriety, and will most likely infuriate the taxpaying and voting public when they find out about  the “double dipping”.  Telling said public that that we are down to 44 waivers for double dipping from the previous 110 is not likely to improve their mood.  Our own Mayor Shayne Gallo can serve as an example to Governor Cuomo.  Do more with less, and do it above-board.

This is too important to be left as a policy with a work-around.  This must be dealt with as a law.

As a solution, I propose the following: The State Legislature should craft and pass a bill outlawing the practice for all public employees. Except in cases of extreme hardship (say, currently earning twice the federal poverty line or less), no public employee, elected, appointed, or hired, may draw funds on the NYS Pension Plan during their time of employment.  Should you retire, begin drawing funds, and then resume work as a public employee, payments are suspended until you leave such employment.  Your private employment after leaving government service does not affect your State Pension, unless you work for a registered lobbyist.

If, however, the Governor feels that the pay for any job is not high enough to keep the proper personnel, he should be free to take the matter up with the legislature, and have them include the increase in the next budget.

The legislature should not be allowed to exempt themselves, their staffs, or anyone from the law.  Legislators and the Governor would, in this one case, avoid the appearance of unethical behavior for passing such a bill.  Waivers would become a thing of the past, and we would all be a little better off.

You can help.  Our own New York Assemblyman Kevin Cahill has spent a great deal of effort on opening up the workings of our government to it’s people.  I am sure he would be interested in hearing from you in support of such legislation.   Newly minted State Senator Cecilia Tkaczyk has said she is looking forward to working with us, as well.  Just scroll over the name and click.  You will end up at the official contact page, and you can let your legislator know what you want.

Cahill and photo

Cahill and Tkaczyk photo

Some will say that this approach is naive.  It may be, but I am sure that it far more naive to expect that our elected officials will make a move to change the way things are without our encouragement and support.

-Andrew Champ-Doran


Posted by on March 23, 2013 in Uncategorized


Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Kingston2025: Are We There Yet?

town hall meet•ing (toun hôl me’ting) n. US

1. (Government, Politics & Diplomacy) an assembly of the inhabitants of a town wherein the citizens and elected officials gather, ostensibly to exercise their constitutional rights to free speech and peacable assembly, but quickly sink to hurling invective, screaming, accusing, and/or threatening each other and future generations with all manner of vile consequences.  [ME tun halle mete < OE tun heall metan]

At least, that’s what it’s become lately.

Civil War imageOne of the reasons I started this blog was because we see far too much of the above.  People get so hot under the collar in so many public fora that they devolve into an “us vs. them” battle.  At times, it is more Civil War than civil discourse.  KingstonBarn is meant as a venue to calmly analyze problems and propose creative solutions.  When I see better results achieved, I want to point that out, too.  Well, last Thursday night, in a relaxed Common Council Chambers, I saw what we can aspire to be.

We had a town hall meeting for the Kingston Comprehensive Development Plan.  Alderman-at-Large Jamesvertical icon for Kingston 2025 Noble, Chairman of the Comprehensive Plan Steering Committee, explained the rules of engagement.  No shouting each other down, no singling people out by name, be respectful, keep it moving.  Each of a dozen tables had a Committee Member Moderator, whose job was to get as many ideas on big 2′ x 3′ paper as people could come up with, list them in categories (Strengths of Kingston, Problems of Kingston, Opportunities of Kingston), and rate the top three from each group.  After all groups were finished, the top three from each were presented to the room as a whole, and every individual voted for their best in the room, signified by distributing six orange dots to your choice.  Noble, as Chairman, set the rules, but what he told me after showed his key to the success for this stage of the process.  He stepped back, he said, and did not try to run things from the head of the room.  His approach was to “…set it up and let it happen.  We want people to help, and this seems like the best way to go about it.”

Was this a diverse group?  You bet.  I sat at a table with Tom, the real estate agent/Moderator, Huntley, an architect who splits his home between New York and Kingston’s waterfront, Vince and Linda, a long-married couple who are long-time residents of Meaghar School District, Emma and Sean, a couple of Onteora High School students here on a civics project, and Beth, who works with Kingston Land Trust and the Hudson River Estuary Program.  Me?  I’ve lived with my beautiful bride of twenty years and our teenaged kids in Kingston’s Third Ward since 2005.

I counted over 100 people in the room.  All of them, from the city officials to the visiting high schoolers, were engaged in the work.  The task at hand, while serious, was not heavy or daunting.  People were involved.  If there were 120 folks there, I am sure there were 600 points for consideration.  Many groups around the room duplicated some of the work of the others, but the boards were filled with creative solutions and thoughtful, interesting views on opportunities and challenges.  The answers covered the entire spectrum, from simple (bolt the street signs so they can’t be turned by vandals), to intricately complicated (simplify zoning and development regulations to encourage new construction and business).  We need the plan to solve the problem.  We haven’t worked on one as far-ranging as this in over 50 years, I’m told.

great-depression-soup-lineWe are not done yet; not by a long shot, as my dad used to say.  This is the end of the first stage of creating a comprehensive plan for Kingston’s future.  The Planning Committee will have to reach conclusions from the data assembled.  The Common Council, and the Mayor will have to create a plan out of those conclusions.  Kingston’s City Planner Suzanne Cahill and her office will have to implement the plan, and we, the citizens of Kingston, will have to carry much of the load along the way.  We will get to 2025, but what shape we are in when we get there depends on the work we are willing to do.

The challenges that face Kingston’s future are no smaller or larger than they were last month, but with so many pitching in on successful town hall meetings like this, they become a little more managable.

Are we there yet?  No, but we have made a good start.

Andrew Champ-Doran


Editor’s note:  To follow the progress of the Kingston 2025 Comprehensive Plan Steering Committee, click on the Kingston2025 logo above.  You will be linked to the City’s website at the Comprehensive Development Plan’s page.  -abcd

1 Comment

Posted by on February 9, 2013 in Uncategorized


Tags: , , , , , , ,

%d bloggers like this: